Tuesday, November 15, 2011

Ad comparisons: then and now.

Ad comparisons: then and now
The first thing that I realized when I was comparing the advertisements from a 1940 magazine to a 2010 magazine was that in the 1940 magazine, there were whole paragraphs inside the advertisements. In the 2010 magazine there were at most a couple sentences inside the advertisement.

The 1940 magazine explained in detail what the product they were advertising was capable of doing and they spread that out over a few paragraphs. The new magazine explained what its product was capable of doing too, but the writers for the new magazine were much more concise and to the point.

The second difference I found was that there seems to be no effort in the 1940 magazine to use a sex appeal in selling a product. In an advertisement for a washing machine, the picture is of an elderly husband and wife standing next to each other and next to the washing machine itself. The other advertisements in this magazine are similar in design to this one. In the newer magazine, there are several advertisements that contain a picture of an attractive man or women using the product that is being advertised and smiling for the camera.

The old magazine also does something we are now taught to avoid doing at all costs. It repeats itself. In the advertisement for the washing machine the writers explain in the three written paragraphs how to operate the washing machine and they also explain exactly what it will do for you. Further down in the advertisement there is a box that also explains how to operate the machine and the box also explains what the machine will do for you.

The most important difference between the advertisements in the two magazines is that in the newer magazine, the price of the product being advertised is almost always given to the reader. In the older magazine however, the price of that product is nowhere to be found in the advertisement. The same goes for information on where you can find and buy the product. Without that information, not nearly as many consumers would be able to buy the product.

The advertisements from the two different magazines were not completely different though. There are some universal advertising rules that have been in use since the start of advertising that show up in all advertisements in both the old and the new magazine.

The biggest similarity is that both magazines try to make their advertisements as visually appealing as possible. The newer magazine uses the sex appeal to do this, but the older magazine has its own way of drawing the reader's eye to the ad. The odl magazine uses several pictures in their advertisements and makes sure to include many different colors to make the ad appealing to the eye.

1 comment:

  1. The assignment asked for a comparison of ads for three products 50 years apart.

    ReplyDelete