Abolish the Death Penalty
Joe Rivet
Should we get rid of the death penalty? Over the years the law has brought many people to justice, but unfortunately it has also brought many innocent people to terrible and deserved punishments.
Many people have been wrongfully imprisoned for long periods of time before the court overturned its decision and many people are still stuck behind bars for crimes they did not commit. But by far the worst punishment that has been inflicted on undeserving people is the death penalty. Many people have received this punishment simply because they were unlucky enough to have no alibi for a crime they did not commit.
This is by far biggest reason to get rid of the death penalty. The possibility that somebody sentenced to death may be innocent and was only proven guilty because some misfortune had befallen them during their trial. There have been many cases over the years with this exact scenario has happened. For example, in 2004 there was a man named Willingham who had a fire burn down his house while his three daughters were inside it. Willingham was charged for arson and the murder of his daughters and was sentenced to death. Then five years later in 2009, the case was reopened and the court changed its ruling to unsustainable, meaning that there was insufficient evidence to execute Willingham.
Willingham is just one of the few unfortunate people that this has happened too. This event shows that it’s too dangerous to sentence someone to death because they might be wrongfully accused and the death penalty is the only penalty there is that is entirely non revocable and once it is done. If the court later overturns its decision there is nothing anyone can do about it and there will be no consolation for the victim of the death penalty or that person’s family.
There is also an extremely practical reason for ending the death penalty. A recent study from a law school showed that 68% have been overturned either because of an error in the court or because DNA tests or other evidence have shown the convicts to be innocent. In many of these cases though, the victim of the death penalty had already been put to death and so it was too late to overturn the sentence.
Many people will argue that the death penalty is necessary because it is the only reasonable punishment for particularly heinous crimes, but let us look at it logically. If a person is accused of murdering someone and proven guilty, is putting that person to death the only reasonable option? Of course not. Simply putting that person in prison for life without parole would accomplish the same thing as putting him to death because the person would not be able to kill any more innocent people.
Another reason for sparing this murderer’s life is that there is always a chance, however slight it might be, that he will be able to change himself and become a functional member of society. There are many accounts of people in prison becoming religious and getting out of prison later as changed people. Killing this murderer would rob him of the chance to change his life around and become a better person.
The final argument that people in favor of the death penalty will put forth is the idea that the death penalty acts as a deterrent for committing terrible crimes. People will be afraid of being put to death and therefore the will be more likely to show restraint out of self-preservation. However if you look over the last century, you will find that this is not the case. In the 20th century, the decade of the 1990s was the only decade that saw an increase in the amount of executions and a decrease in violent crimes at the same time. In a few other decades in the last century it was the other way around and the country would see an increase in the number of executions and an increase in violent crime rates at the same time. The fact that it is rare for an increase in death penalties to cause a decrease in violent crime shows that the death penalty is actually not an effective deterrent.
Finally I would like to end this by pointing out that the United States is one of the very few democracies left in the world that still insists on having the death penalty. The death penalty needs to be abolished.
No comments:
Post a Comment